Filewrapper

Federal Circuit provides more detail on FDA research exemption to infringement

The Federal Circuit recently decided a case on remand from the Supreme Court's decision regarding the research exception to patent infringement (35 U.S.C. § 271(e)(1), "The FDA exception"). The Federal Circuit reversed the district court's finding of infringement, holding that the experiments were not infringements because they were reasonably related to research that would be […]

Continue Reading →

Federal Circuit affirms findings of patent and copyright noninfringement

In a recent decision the Federal Circuit affirmed a district court's grant of summary judgment of noninfringement on one count of patent infringement and two counts of copyright infringement. The Federal Circuit also upheld the district court's denial of the plaintiff's Rule 60(b) motion seeking vacatur of the summary judgments. More details of Hutchins v. […]

Continue Reading →

Same terms, same meanings, unless specification indicates otherwise

In an appeal by Porta Stor, Inc. of a judgment in favor of PODS, Inc. for, among other things, patent and copyright infringement, the Federal Circuit reversed the judgment of patent infringement finding no literal infringement and finding that infringement under the doctrine of equivalents was barred by prosecution history estoppel. The court also reversed […]

Continue Reading →

Willful infringement affirmed; injunction vacated in light of eBay

The Federal Circuit affirmed a finding of willful infringement against a medical device manufacturer, but vacated a permanent injunction entered based on the old injunction standard to be reevaluated by the district court in light of the Supreme Court’s decision in eBay v. MercExchange. The infringer obtained opinions of counsel regarding infringement at two different […]

Continue Reading →

Comparison of Commercial Products not the vehicle to analyze equivalence

In a second appearance before the Federal Circuit, AquaTex again appealed a decision of the District Court that Techniche Solutions’ Cooling Apparel did not infringe their U.S. Patent No. 6,371,977 for a protective multi-layered liquid retaining composition. The Federal Circuit had previously affirmed the lower court’s finding of no literal infringement while remanding the case […]

Continue Reading →

Federal Circuit reverses claim construction but affirms infringement

Abraxis Bioscience (formerly AstraZeneca) is the holder of three patents on an improved formulation of an anesthetic, DIPRIVAN?. Prior formulations had the problem of increasing postoperative infections. The inventors discovered that by adding disodium edetate as an antimicrobial agent. This addition allowed DIPRIVAN? to be administered for up to 24 hours without a significant increased […]

Continue Reading →

Stay in Touch

Receive the latest news and updates from us and our attorneys.

Sign Up